⚠️ NOTE: DO NOT STOP HERE. This is just Part 1 (The Emotional Prelude) focusing on the trauma behind Hadith rejection. Part 2, 3, and 4 drop next as a forensic lockdown to completely dismantle the “Quran-Only” ideology and prove why our history is bulletproof.
In this video, we explore why Muslim youth are drawn to Hadith rejection, tracing it back to broken hearts and harsh religious environments, before turning to examples from the Prophet’s ﷺ life that model compassion and laying out why the Sunnah is essential to properly practicing Islam.
0:00 – Start With the Heart
1:13 – Where Rebellion Begins
2:42 – Expecting Safety, Finding Coldness
4:00 – Hadith as a Weapon
5:08 – A Compassionate Prophet ﷺ
6:17 – The Trauma Logic
7:55 – Three Examples
8:39 – Don’t Help Shaytan
11:24 – Modern-Day Mobs
14:01 – The Slander of Aisha (RA)
21:37 – The Quarrel & Abu Bakr’s Rebuke
25:46 – Correcting Without Shaming
28:02 – A Message to the Hurting
30:41 – Addressing Hadith Rejection
33:28 – Preserving the Sunnah
==============================================
Support Us: https://www.belalassaad.com.au/donate
Subscribe to Email list: https://www.belalassaad.com.au/email-opt-in
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/belal.assaad/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@belal.assaad
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/officialbelalassaad
Podcast: https://tr.ee/QaaCJeM6qZ
source
This talk was just the first layer.Turn your notifications on for my upcoming 3-part lecture series: "Dismantling the 'Quran-Only' Ideology and False Claims."
I needed to hear this because of a situation in which people accuse my Daughter🙏🏿❤️
May Allah bestow sakina upon you❤️
Jazakallah Khair! This deeply renewed my love for our Prophet (PBUH) and my closeness to Allah. May Allah elevate your rank in Jannah for this.
Jazak Allah. Allah bless all who make effort for the truth.🎉
Like this comment if you were ever silenced using Hadith when you sought justice and tried to make sense of your situation. What these scholars get so wrong is defend defend defend the Quran and Hadith but never acknowledge the oppression women and children endure at the hands of men using these Hadiths and Quran.
Like this comment if you are a woman who was raped by her husband using Hadith. It’s important that these scholars understand the impact these Hadiths have on our mothers, daughters, sisters at the hands of men who are supposed to protect them.
Like this comment if you’ve even been called a Kuffar. Like this comment if you’ve ever been spiritually abused using Hadith. It’s important that these scholars understand the lived experiences of people.
Jazak'Allah Khairan
جزاك الله خيرا
And the biggest question remains: Did God authenticate Al-Bukhari's collection Hadiths?
9:1 is dissociation from mushriks
In context of peace treaty/ 9:13,
Because they broke the peace,
So your Hadith is misleading.
Merely cherry picking Hadiths
Isn't gonna help you against us,
There is an enormeous amount
Of nasty Hadiths in your Bukhari.
You trying to mislead people from Quran
Is clearly your own delusion again here.
HasbunAllah.
I don’t see hadith collection is the teachings of the prophet. There is a living Sunnah and hadith that all of you scholars still cannot agree on interpretation. Why do you guys lack knowledge on explaining the word of Allah? When he already told us that the Quran is complete!
Hadith is DEAD
Literally have no words, other then belal Assad is such an amazing speaker. He healed so much. Even though I would never be a Hadith rejector, but the WAY he intellectually and eloquently expressed the experience of woman. May Allah always keep him rightly guided. May He grant him good health and increase his wisdom so he can continue his work. AMEEN
❤
Interesting trauma 😊
I know you said you make duaa for those who call you names, etc, but I also want to say sorry that you get told those things🌷🪷
With regards to Quran only being around for 100+ years, I’d argue they’ve been here since the inception of the Sunni-Shia divide formally began. Heck, probably all the way back into the Umayyad and the Abbasid Caliphates. It’s only recently been popularized to the extent that it has now thanks to modern technology and science placing Hadith resources on the forefront.
I will also point at 32:44 because there exists some Hadith that are, ‘interesting’ for lack of a better terminology and don’t quite make sense in my opinion. There’s a lot to address with the sahih hadith corpus.
But overall, you are completely right and brother, I thank you so much for this lecture and I look forward towards your series on Hadith! Keep up the great work, inshallah!
Thank you so much for this beautiful video, your kind words and heart are a gift to us. May Allah bless you for all the good you do
This is old he must have reuploaded it smart man
Opening the topic with empathy is so important. And I love that the sheikh mentioned how this isn’t just a topic to broach from a knowledge angle, may Allah reward him in his efforts and compassion. While a topic like this can’t be summed up in a comment, and the severity of the misguidance and fitna should not be understated or left uncritically examined, there is a real frustration and valid resentment that’s bubbled up in girls and women for years that leads to these jahil notions, and it’s not just “western feminism infiltrates our women.” It’s not that simple.
I spent most of my youth in survival mode, women and girls were unappreciated everywhere, wives and mother disrespected, every one concerned with presentability like hijab and what you can or can’t do in islam yet there was a disturbing lack of care for the feelings and heart of a person. It becomes too easy to fall for the western trap with sweet words of feminism, empowerment and the dignity or respect young girls always craved but could never feel.
Many of these women are hurt in their own way and I pray Allah guides them to truth. That is not to excuse behaviour and misleading ideas that need to be confronted, like hadith rejection as the idea its more liberating. That is not to appease anything going against islam.
But someome had to say out loud what girls and women carry with them all throughout their developmental years. These conversations need to be had.
Bilal bhai. I have one request in every long khutbah give 5 to 7 mins and introduce Islam in the best way and then proceed to the topic. This help our not yet muslim brother to know about Islam in every post
But it’s not really the best forensic methodology as of today’s standards maybe 1200 years ago I’m not a rejector but I am critical just as the scholars were who had to create forensic methodologies to declare what might and what might not be true
You can not understand the rage I feel towards these self righteous people who weaponize Hadith agaisnt another person. They want to define the relationship the other person has with Allah through their nafs. Centering themselves between the person they are oppressing and Allah. I feel so much rage, because it’s egregious behavior and they have the audacity to call the oppressed kuffur.
Thank you very much for this important lecture, Sheikh Belal. Could you please do a full lecture specifically addressing the arguments for rejecting Hadith and explaining why Hadith should be accepted?
Questioning hadiths isn't trauma; it's historical and textual research based on the Quran being complete and detailed. Stick to the theology, not pop psychology.
writing here already after listening only to your first few words Sheikh, because I realize that hearing your calm, familiar voice does something to me, makes me relax, feel confident, and let go of stress.
You are my favourite Sheikh for your beautiful wisdom AND for talking so calmly and neither raising your voice nor a pointer finger, but just being a brother who learned far more than us. Thank you for all your teachings and may Allah bless you ❤
amd now back to your video
In which Hadith after Allah and his verses do they uphold?
If one to be believers ,one follow what revealed and what was revealed before
JAK sheikh. This was such a much needed lecture at a much needed time!
Sheikh you’re so smart, thank you for providing a different perspective. Back when I heavily believed in law of attraction, only when I saw your video on it is when I changed my mind and realised I had been following shirk❤
I know that there are no coincidences. I am a revert and not a youth. There is one question I have- I grew up in an unspeakable contaminated family- even so – when my mother was dying I went to stay with her to prevent my brother from putting her in a nursing home. I told him I was staying with her until her last
breath .
The hospice workers names were Hope and Faith. one of the ministers came out and asked me to return to her bedside because she whispered to the minister that she needed my permission to die. I have never heard of anyone doing that? Perhaps she was telling me to go back home to my family- she told me 2 weeks before her death that I was physically sick . As it turned out I was misdiagnosed with pancreatic cancer- saved by a muslim doctor with the help of Allah! To make a long story short I survived three near death experiences and lost my oldest daughter.
After washing her body and throwing the first three handfuls of sand it began to storm. Very heavy rain. It was right at this moment that something shifted in me- I now see Allah doesn’t authorize anything to happen without showing you the mercy in his time not mine.
I’m still being tested – But am grateful for your lectures and the things I have learned from you.
I have watched your journey and your story.May Allah be pleased with your relentless gift of teaching and clear translation for people that are struggling.
.
.
My friend who was a very practising Muslim is today a very practising Christian. First step was Hadith rejection. So be careful if you are walking down this path.
This is a much needed talk…the youth need to follow true scholars of the deen who provide Islamic guidance and knowledge..too many of our youth are being corrupted by cowboy scholars..it needs to be rectified. Alhumdulillah for u sheikh ❤❤❤
Sa, where is the fine line between Hadiths where our prophet stated not to write about him to avoid this exact problem? Yet why do we still not listen?
Brother belal great lecture, but one minor correction the first verse of surat al tawbah was not revealed because of aisha (as)
Masha Allah Shiek, very important topic during this period of time,
Quran (Factory setting)&Hadeeth(Manual) Without Manual how to understand the factory setting,
Jazakallahu Hairan Sheik you are doing good work for the community !!!
I am truly grateful that Allah allowed you to talk about this issues in our community.
I noticed that many people leave/don't practice Islam ☪️ because of the wrong that's been done to them by people they believed to be righteous, or abuse from religious family members.
May Allah allow us to practice the religion in a way that pleases Him. Ameen
The Prophet ﷺ fiercely protected people's dignity and told the community, "Do not assist Satan against your brother." True religious excellence means people feel safe around us, not judged. Thank you for addressing this with so much compassion and nuance. May Allah reward you.
Questions abt Hadith is a matter of trust.
After being inspired by you to wake up early, I’ve officially become a morning person, 😊Alhamdulillah!
I even started a YouTube channel to document my Islamic journey.🥹
Please call me. Salt Lake City is giving fake reads to avoid judgement. They r avoiding final judgement. They try to pretend it’s for my endorsement. It’s not. It them being given more room before the court of God. America suit up.
Alhamdulillah 🤲🏻 Sheikh Assad is a wonderful man, we are truly blessed to learn from him. May Allah SWT reward him for his efforts and sharing of knowledge.
❤
Sharing a thought:
The result of voluntarily or involuntarily misunderstood/misused Hadith’s has been that muslims are reaching out to their fundament, which is the Quran.
That shift isn't inherently bad. The Quran is our absolute anchor, and turning to it helps clear the haze created by environments that over-rely on Hadith. But going Quran-only means missing out on vital wisdom, context, and practical lessons from the Sunnah.
The core issue, in my humble opinion (I am not a scholar)… We seem to rarely verify or question Hadith against the Quran first—even when they are classified as sahih (authentic).
Allah SWT constantly invites us in the Quran to reflect (tadabbur) and think critically. If the Quran itself welcomes that level of reflection, our first reflex with Hadith—or any religious writing—should be to study it critically, reflect, and measure it against the Quran first.
May Allah (SWT) bless you brother
Yeah hadiths are very handy for understanding.
Love this man's lectures ❤️🩹
Allahu Akbar subhanAllah Alhamdulillah Masha Allah Ameen ❤❤❤❤❤
Asa Brotha
I love your lectures because you deal with the intellectual meaning of the Quran. I seek in the knowledge and understanding. Islam has taught me so about myself as a human being especially about envy and jealousy. Your teachings open my mind up more to a spiritual enlightenment. Alhamdulilah